DCI Barnaby and DS Nelson investigate the fatal stabbing of a man with an antique sword during a ghost-hunting party at a ‘haunted’ manor house. Is blacksmith’s daughter Rose Wilton seeking revenge from the beyond the grave, or can Barnaby and Nelson find a more earthly motive behind the murder and trap the killer?
As Christmas descends on Morton Shallows, a new Detective Sergeant arrives in the name of Charlie Nelson. However, unrest soon breaks out as local furniture maker and serial philanderer Conor Bridgeman is stabbed to death with an antique sword during a ghost-hunting party. The owner of the house, Simon Fergus-Johnson and the rest of his family are astonished when they discover their new venture has gone horrifically wrong. Brendan Pearce, a local historian, is quick to accuse the blacksmith's daughter, Rose Wilton. But there's just one problem; Rose is a ghost...
Conor's widow Mel is stunned to learn he was cheating on her with her singing teacher, Felicity Hearn. More secrets are spilled when it appears Conor had attempted to negotiate with Fergus to buy the haunted manor, but the discussion was fractious. Beliefs continue to lure in the air when Ross Clymer, landlord of local pub Blacksmith Arms, brands his pub as an "original haunted site". There's also a recording of the night Conor died, with a ghost-like girl's voice in the background.
Simon's wife Tabby keeps close contact with Ross. Brendan has high hopes that Conor's death will boost the café and shop he runs with wife Libs. Valerie Fergus-Johnson gets in contact with Barnaby, and tells him that she was her father's carer from the age of thirteen, and that Simon had toured the world before inheriting the manor. Simon and Tabby row as the manor lies in disorder, ignoring daughter Pippa. Pippa decides to wonder off, going in search for Dev Kardek, a student obsessed in the paranormal. When she finds him he seems busy writing his PhD.
Mel visits Felicity, while Barnaby discovers Brendan's fixation over village matters began after Conor broke his daughter's heart - resulting in her leaving home. Despite the motives in place, Brendan denies murdering Conor.
Army major Ollie Tabori returns to the village of Morton Shallows, and instantly searches for Valerie. When Ollie arrives in the pub, Ross is furious and chucks him out. Pippa and Dev plan a vigil regarding part of their studies. As night dawns, the pub is in lock-down where Ross prepares to search for the ghost in his pub. He is joined by several residents. Nelson stands by as the lights are switched off and the hunt begins. He sees something and head off to investigate, trapping Felicity who is playing the tape of the ghostly girl's voice. As the lights are switched back on and the residents gather, they realise Ross is missing. He's been bludgeoned to death with a blacksmith's hammer.
Nelson later discovers that Ollie is in fact Mel's brother, and was once Valerie's lover. He also discovers Ollie was sent off after causing an accident. However, Ollie never did cause the accident as the real culprits were Conor and Ross. Ollie then went AWOL from the army, suffering PTSD. Is Ollie actually seeking revenge? Brendan disappears, but he's taken cash with him.
Nelson learns Dev tricked Pippa, as his PhD is truly about paranormal gullibility. Suddenly the mystery pieces together and Barnaby and Nelson realise who's really behind these killings. They rush towards supposedly-haunted caves, where Pippa plans a live transmission to mark the one-hundred-and-twenty-seventh anniversary of Rose. But will they arrive in time? Or will the killer strike a third time?
- Neil Dudgeon as DCI John Barnaby
- Gwilym Lee as DS Charlie Nelson
- Fiona Dolman as Sarah Barnaby
- Tamzin Malleson as Kate Wilding
- Mark Heap as Simon Fergus-Johnson
- Nadia Cameron-Blakey as Tabby Fergus-Johnson
- Hannah Tointon as Pippa Fergus-Johnson
- Emily Joyce as Valerie Fergus-Johnson
- James Murray as Ollie Tabori
- Les Dennis as Brendan Pearce
- Elizabeth Berrington as Libs Pearce
- Susie Trayling as Mel Bridgeman
- Jonah Russell as Conor Bridgeman
- Perdita Avery as Felicity Hearn
- Nikesh Patel as Dev Kardek
- Paul Blair as Ross Clymer
- Abigail Clarke as Sophie - Singing School Girl (uncredited)
- Pamela Betsy Cooper as Christmas Shopper (uncredited)
- Chris Cowlin as CID Officer (uncredited)
- Anthony Farrelly as Criminal Investigation Department Officer (uncredited)
- Chris Wilson as Police Officer (uncredited)
Midsomer Murders Series 16 Episode 1 - The Christmas Haunting Preview
Interview with Mark Heap
Interview with Les Dennis
- First appearance of DS Charlie Nelson.
The following actors and actresses who appeared in this episode have also appeared in the following episodes
- Emily Joyce - A Worm in the Bud
- Nadia Cameron-Blakey - Master Class
- Pamela Betsy Cooper - Schooled in Murder, The Killings of Copenhagen, The Dagger Club, Murder by Magic and Breaking the Chain
- The Christmas Haunting at Wikipedia